Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Chicago Divorce Lawyers / Blog / Family Law Hague Convention / The Hague Convention Is Not a Custody Trial: What a Court Must Actually Decide When a Child Is Taken Abroad

The Hague Convention Is Not a Custody Trial: What a Court Must Actually Decide When a Child Is Taken Abroad

WorriedLady

Few things frighten a parent more than a child who does not come home from a trip overseas. In that moment, many people expect a judge to decide who the better parent is. A Hague case works differently. The Chicago Hague Convention lawyers at Arnoux Sharma Standeford, LLC handle these cases, and the first thing to understand is that the court asks a narrow question: should this child go back to the country where he or she lived?

Wrongful Removal Is the Starting Point

Under Article 3 of the Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, a removal or retention is wrongful when it breaches custody rights under the law of the child’s habitual residence and those rights were actually being exercised. Article 4 limits the treaty to a child who lived in a Contracting State right before the breach, and it stops applying at age 16.

In practice, a court asks:

  • Where did the child habitually live just before the removal or retention?
  • Did the left-behind parent have custody rights under that place’s law?
  • Were those rights actually being exercised?
  • Is the child under 16?

Federal law lets the petition be filed in state or federal court where the child is located, and the petitioner must prove wrongful removal by a preponderance of the evidence under 22 U.S.C. 9003. If a child is brought to the Chicago area, that means a court here can hear the case.

The One-Year Mark and the Exceptions

Article 12 says that when less than one year has passed, the court must order return forthwith. After a year, return is still required unless the child is settled in the new environment. Article 13 adds defenses, including consent or acquiescence, a grave risk of physical or psychological harm, and a mature child’s objection. The parent resisting return must prove the grave risk defense, along with Article 20, by clear and convincing evidence under 22 U.S.C. 9003(e)(2).

What a Hague Case Leaves Untouched

Article 19 states that a return decision is not a ruling on the merits of custody. That decision belongs to the courts of the child’s home country.

The numbers show why speed matters. The State Department’s 2026 Annual Report on International Child Abduction says it handled 908 active abduction cases in 2025, including 845 in which parents sought a child’s return, involving 1,164 children. Of those, 414 cases were new that year, and 256 children came back to the United States.

If your child has been taken or kept abroad, call experienced Chicago Hague Convention attorneys at Arnoux Sharma Standeford, LLC right away. The clock in Article 12 is real, and the first weeks often shape everything that follows.

Sources:

hcch.net/en/instruments/conventions/full-text/?cid=24

travel.state.gov/content/dam/NEWIPCAAssets/2026%20-%20Annual%20Report%20on%20International%20Child%20Abduction.pdf

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
+